1 Topic by revan07 (edited by revan07 Friday, July 11, 2008 3:28 am)

Topic: Percentage of each film

What would you give each Star Wars film out of 100. Also include what the average film would get for you.

This is my list

TPM 100%
AOTC 100%(80% until they get to geonosis then it picks up)
ROTS 100%(100% all the way. It is emotionally the most powerfull of the saga and the battles are the best. And the plot is perfect)
ANH 100%
TESB 100%
ROTJ 100%

average film 60%

"My luck ranges from barely tolerable to cataclysmic"

Re: Percentage of each film

hmm

TPM - 100, 99 cuz of Jar Jar and Anakin being whiny
AOTC - 80, the romance was boring and could've been cut out, or at least acted better, the fighting was good
ROTS - 100, get rid of the romance, or do it better! fighting was beast
the original trilogy defines Epic, so they all get 100, no problems

Re: Percentage of each film

You're much more generous then I:

TPM 60% - kid who played Anakin couldn't act to save himself and Darth Maul was underused
AOTC 80% - the "love story" was rubbish, the destruction of Boba's EU past, but Obi Wan's story was great
ROTS 80% - Padme died so predicably and lamely but we got to see more clone trooper action
ANH 100% - The original and the best, Luke's whining does become endearing... eventually tongue
TESB 95% - The first intro to Boba!
ROTJ 95% - Luke becomes a Jedi, Ewoks beat Stormtroopers at Paper, Scissors, Rock tongue

BFFC Moderator
It was like thousands of voices cried out for a sequel and were suddenly silenced...

Re: Percentage of each film

Bobas past was better after AOTC

"My luck ranges from barely tolerable to cataclysmic"

Re: Percentage of each film

also edit your posts to include what you give films on average

"My luck ranges from barely tolerable to cataclysmic"