Topic: Which is better: KOTOR or KOTOR 2?

which is better
Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic or
Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic 2 The Sith Lords

KotOR I had the greatest twist and best story of ANY of the SW movies; maybe the equel of "No Luke.......I am your father"

KotOR II left me more confused at the end then I was in the begining.........  Lots of good upgrades over KotOR I in the graghics and item departments, but story was lacking and, as I said, confusing.......to me at least

i think the kotor 1 story is the best, 100%. almost as good as revenge of the sith in my opinion

i just think they could have done more with the war, maybe show scenes that make it clear the republic is losing and how the huge the Sith fleet is

kotor 2 ending i thought was pretty bad, the kotor 2 story was pretty good, about as good as Return of the Jedi but when the Jedi were all killed on dantooine the story just collapsed

What else do i need to say? Alor you pinned it down right there. Although the "Vader being Luke's father" wasn't really shocking by the time I was born and watching the movies.... the twist in KotOR had me ..." WHAT! NO WAY! NO WAY!" it was fantastic.

TSL... didn't really have a moment like that... there was some good game play.. .all up to the end... where you lose and confuse me.  I wish they spent the time fixing that.

the only problem i really have with KOTOR 1 is to little about the war
the twist was fantatic, i suspected it at one point on Manaan before the Leviathan but i thought that would be to impossible of a twist

Yes, KOTOR 1 was great, and it had Canderous *MY HERO :D*, but KOTOR 2 had many more mandalorians!  And it was easier to get and wear their armor.  So I like then about equally

it was fun with many madndalororians on dxun but the K2 ending was a huge let-down

Very true.

The Mandalorian element to KotOR II is what saved it for me.  If not for that, nearly the game as a whole would have been a let down to me.  Too many of the missions FORCE you to finish them out; you don't have the option to take off and go to another world for a break if you get stuck or board.  It's ok on Dxun, that's a really fun mission, but the first 2 *Peragus and Telos* can be a real drag at times.

KotOR 1 was amazing, much better then KotOR 2, i believe that KotOR 2 had a lot of potential but failed because they tried to finish the game for shipping rather then postponing it to make the game better itself.

KOTOR 1 because Carth Onasi was in it pretty much 24/7 (yummmy man ;))

KotOR 1, i love the storyline more, and Revan kicks ass.

For all those who like the KOTOR games and if you like the new Star Wars Miniatures games, check out what they're coming out with this August. 

http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=starwars/article/KOTORminis

I like the Mandalore box cover art.

Those look really good Sadriel, and yeah, the Mandalore one looks great!  My only question would be.....................WHERE IS REVAN??!!??

Whos the guy in the middle? Looks like Obi-one to me...though I've not played the game, so I recognize no one.

Yeah, it does look like Obi-Wan.

For me it would be the original KOTOR, I was addicted and I've played it numerous times. I got so far into KOTOR 2 and thought it got boring then never went back to it.

The ending of K2 was ridiculous, how come at one point the Hawk is damaged and half destroyed and the next its in prime condition(And its Malachor their on so there wouldn't be a repair station down the road)

I'd give KotOR 1 100% and kotor 2 75%

All the Star Wars movies i give 100%

I love both games, but I'm going to have to go with KOTOR I.

KOTOR II wasn't as good because they rushed through the ending. If they waitied a couple more months, the game would've been alot better.

Yeah. Kreia was really easy. Game was really easy. I'm talking about KotOR 2. :mad: