Topic: Alien vs Predator

Sorry if this has been done before(ignoring the 2 movies).

but who would win
mr alien dude
or
mr predator

Alien has much more stealth, if they can get close they are much more lethal, predator had better tech, if they see the alien coming they win.

Alien, their number grow fast, and they take trates from their face hugged victems, which can make them tough (predalien for example)

Imagine a Rhino Alien :D

plus, like if an alien gets blown up, its blood is gonna finish who ever is lands on.

I agree with AA.

who won in the 2 movies?

Predator won - just - in the first one. Haven't seen the second one as yet.

One thing for the Predator, the Aliens' acid blood doesn't affect them. I think older more experienced Predators would be able to defeat the aliens. We're only seen films made about the juvenilles trying to prove themselves. After all humans are considered "Soft Meat" while aliens are considered "Hard Meat".

It would be far more interesting if instead you made this thread AVC instead AVP. (Aliens versus Clones :P)

Well it doesn't effect the Predators armour, it does effect them if it hits their bare skin

The new movie AvPR confirmed what I would have said before seeing it: it's Predator all the way. 

*SPOILER AHEAD A_A*

The single predator wastes aliens right and left in that one, and in several cases more then one at once, settling the debate right there.  It takes the part-Predator Alien to even get him at a tie

*END SPOILERS*

Remember Jesse, the topic is 'Alien vs. Predator,' implying one-on-one.  I don't think the Alien rate of growth comes into affect here

seemed like there was more than one alien in Alien Vs Predator!

But still, Alien would win, in my opinion Despite what happend in the movies. I didnt like the new AvP, those strauss guys got a little too cocky bragging how its so much better than AvP 1, and it still failed! even more so than the first (I'm basing this on rotten tomatos.com) If there is an AvP 3 it should be left to James Cameron.

This is a Vs. thread; it's just coincedence that it's the same name as the movie.  Unless Revan07 wants to specify differently, this is a one-on-one match-up.

The new AvP was better then the first one, but not by a lot.  The only big improvment in my view was the performance of the Predators vs the Aliens *if you don't count the opening scene......which I don't really  :P *.  So if you're not really a Predator fan, that 'improvement might not seem like much.  The acting still sucked bigtime.  I guess the CGI cost so much they couldn't get good actors like in the old Predator and Alien movies....

I've kinda always considered their rapid reproduction and their large numbers to be one of their strengths and to be taken as a point for them in match ups.

Their method of reproduction and numbers ARE there greatest weapon I think, but there's no way to guage that that I know of.  And the opening post was pretty specific, "MR. alien dude vs. MR predator." 

Without the reproduction/numbers factor, I think it's pretty easy, at least if you're talking about an experienced Predator.  Even a less then experienced one would have a solid edge I think

Predators owned in the first AVP, haven't seen the second one because I heard that it wasn't as good as the first.

The first one sucked. A lot.

Let us not forget that the Alien was a biological weapon, designed to destroy populations of entire planets. Their numbers and reproduction methods help with this, but a single alien is stealthy and incredibly deadly in close range combat

So is the Predator, more so in my opinion *Coughcloaking-devise/ALL-their-weapons-besides-shoulder-cannonCough*

Cloaking has no effect on aliens, and plasma caster is only effective at medium to long range. Disc is also ineffective, if an alien can get close, and I assure you, they can, it could kill a predator. Or did you forget that all of its limbs, including its tail are deadly. Its jaws can crack through a predator's faceplate. And even if it kills it at close range combat its going to get splattered with acid, if it hits the predator's skin it could easily kill him.

No matter what happens with those aliens, Predator stands tall yet again.

Of course if he was going to die...wrist nuke...

The second one was better, but the ending made the whole movie kinda pointless.

Predators hunt Aliens for fun. If they couldn't win, I don't think they would keep doing it.

AA, the discs are very effective. In the second movie, a Yautja takes an Alien's arms off with them.

one on one, the predators seem to be stronger while the aliens are fast.
if you really want to get technical, even close combat or in a large space would effect the outcome.
with weapons,the predators would win. without.....the predator would have to be very lucky, or very experienced.

Lets break it down:
Predator vs xenomorph based on a human = Predator Wins

Predator vs xenomoph based on dog (ex alien 3) = Predator Wins

Predator vs Alien Queen = Alien Queen wins

Predator vs xenomorph based on predator = Tie withh both dead

Now here is the tough on the live berth Alien from Ressurection? It was tough but not bright.

The other thing is what arena open or confined, in the open the Predators have a definate advantage because of ranged weapons in close it depends on the skill of the predators.  Predator armour is vunerable to the Aliens acid blood, the spear, dagger, shuriken are not but the wrist blades and constricting net can be destroyed by the Alien blood.

In the first AVP movie, a slightly injured Yautja takes down a Queen. I think. It's been a while since I've seen it.

No they cant, atleast according to the books

He severly injured it but it was the apprentace hunter that finally drown the queen.  But in the movies the armour, net and wrist blades can be destroyed by the acid blood, that is what made the Grid alien.

True about the armor, it snapped when it broke the skin of the Alien and it started to bleed all over it.  Not so sure about the wrist blades though.  I don't remember them being damaged in the first AvP *might have been; been a while since I've seen it* but in the new one the Pred. uses it to kill the PredAlien; didn't notice any damage to them there

PREDATOR ALL THE WAY. even though the aliens come in greater numbers predators have nukes have an array of weapons and are very stylish. aliens are just stealthy and more hand-to-hand combat based.
im such a nerd at times:):):).
IM ADDICTED TO THE SMILEYS

I liked the alien hybrid, but the rest of the movie is delayed, Alien movies were incredible, and the same film true predator, AVP, and had the opportunity to be a good movie. This idea has actually had a brilliant idea. I loved AVP one was still standing when the predator to humans. I also played the multiplayer demo and was not really satisfied with either. The controls seem crooked, and I do not know what I am doing half the time.