Topic: Boba Fett vs Master Chief vs Gordon Freeman

Well, my brother and I were disscusing who was better, Boba Fett vs Master Chief vs Gordon Freeman. Decideding immeadiately that any strait up "So and so would kill whoever so fast his life would flash before his eyes in fast forward" debate would be pointless, we made a comparison list and this is what I came up with:

1.Armour
Fett: His Mandolorian Armour is pitted and scared, contains more hidden weapons then all the middle east combind, and gives off a vibe of complete and utter doom.  It also fails to cover a large part of his body, leaving him exposed to attack in any of his joints.
Cheif: Surrounded in his MJOLNIR armor, he has enhanced reflexis and strength, a the ability to store a "smart" artificial intelligence (Cortana is not included with the suit), not to speak of a incredible regenerating sheild.  It is also bulky, hiders acrobatic movments, and is an unholy shade of green.
Freeman: His smart Hev suit has a flashlight, radio, Geiger counter, morphine administrator, anti-toxin delivery system and a chargeable "sheild" of sorts, all run by a built in A.I.  It is also a tolerable shade of colors and is gap free.
Winner: Freeman.  Fett in a close second and Cheif in third.
2.Helmet.
Fett: Contains all sorts of vision and hearing enanchers, voice command links, jamming and scaning equipment, is nigh indestructable, and is just plain cool looking.
Cheif:  It keeps him from getting his head taken off by a plasma bolt...  Oh, it has a flashlight too.
Freeman: What helmet? (Yeah, come on, even if he does he never wears it.)
Winner: Fett.  He is his mask for Pete's sake.  Cheif gets second because at least he's got a helmet.
3.Weapons
Fett: He has a modifed EE-3 carbine rifle, a Tenloss DXR-6 disruptor rifle, a blaster pistol, and a uncountable number of weapons in his armour.
Cheif: A few human made projectile based weapons and whatever alien weapons he can scavenge.  The needler is obscenely cool. The rest are simply standerd weapons.
Freeman: A couple of normal pistols, a SMG, grenades, guided RPG's, a shotgun, a crossbow, and a Overwatch Standard Issue Pulse Rifle.
Winner: Fett, duh. Freeman and Cheif tie, on account of needler/OSIPR tie.
4. Gadgettes
Fett: False eye/finger scanners, tracking devices, and other items helpfull in breaking and entry.
Cheif: Uhh...I can whack things with the butt of my gun...
Freeman: A nifty crowbar and a Gravity gun.  What am I saying! It's a freaking Zero-point energy gun! The enviroment is my plaything! Mwaaahaha!
Winner: Freeman. It's not even close.  All hail the Gravity gun!!! All Hail!!! Fett 2nd, Cheif 3rd.
5.Strength
Fett: Preety strong.
Cheif: I can bench press a Warthog and not even break a sweat.
Freeman: Well, he's preety str...oh, what am I saying.  He can't even climb over a chest high wall.
Winner: Cheif.  Fett comes in second, with Freeman trailing miserably in third.
6.Stamina:
Fett: I can chase after my merchendice for a while...
Cheif: I run for three day without eating.  Heck, I can fight an alien armada while continuously hopping for three days without sleeping or eating.
Freeman: I can run for about a minute. Less, if my flashlight is on.
Winner: Cheif again. Fett 2nd and puffing away in third is good old freeman.
7.Intelligence:
Fett: Bounty Hunting, while sharpening the mind, is more blue collar than white collar...
Cheif: If it doesn't involve killing, it's not worth knowing...
Freeman: He's a theoretical physicist for cying out loud.
Winner: Freeman. Fett barely beats Cheif.
8.Allies
Fett: What allies?
Cheif: A couple of marines, and one good looking A.I.
Freeman: The human resistance, an alien race, a bunch of scientists, and (if you've got the bugbait) Antlions.
Winner: Freeman and Cheif tie. Fett wins too, but in a different way.
9.Agility:
Fett: I jump, roll, flip, dive, and whatever else needs be done.  I'd give an olympic gymnast a run for their money.
Cheif: I get close, but this armour won't let me do a handspring.
Freeman: I'm a theoretical physicist, not a physical therapist.
Winner: Fett, than Chief, then freeman.
10. Enemies.
Fett: He picks and choose's who he's going to take on for the most part.  And he fights the scum of the galaxy, not the empire.  Heck, he works for the empire.
Cheif:  An alien race bent on our destruction and space zombies that threaten galaxy wide destruction.
Freeman: An alien race bent on our destruction and zombies.
Winner: Freeman and Cheif tie.  I mean, fett, you're cool and all, but I don't find your enemies all that bad.
11. Persona
Fett: The most heartless being in the galaxy. Emotionless and fearless, he is his mask and his mask is him.
Chief: To his enemies, the deamon.  The one being that hants them, who's appeance causes them to flee in utter terror.  To his allies, a living weapon capable of single handedly keeping the enemy at bay.
Freeman: To his allies, a messiah figure, a bond breaker (to the vortigaunts at least), "the last free man".  To his enemies, a simply man.  Not a soldier, not a warrior with advanced weapons training, just a simple man who will just not die.
Winner: They all win this one.
Tally: (2 points for 1st, 1 for 2nd. Ties score the same.)
Fett: 13 points
Cheif: 13 points
Freeman: 13 points

Well, it's a three way tie.  I'll add more later but I'm too dang tierd now.  So, if you disagree, agree, or think I missed something post below and I'll change the totals later.

Edit: In retrospect this is an obscenely long post.  Sorry everone for forcing you to read this.

This belongs in the role playing section.

aye, i was about to say the same thing.

Other than your Armor logic, I actually completely agree with you. (though I still don't consider Freeman to have any chance against Fett or Chief... but no point in starting in on that right now)

Failing to cover a large part of his body is right. This is a fatal flaw as it is not only his shoulder or elbows... but his whole bicep and thigh areas. Big Big targets.

Bulky yes, hinders acrobatic movements... maybe a little, but you make him sound like a tank. (good armor but he is a sitting duck). He has been clocked in armor at about 60kph (about 37mph). If he has the ability to run that fast, I don't think it "hinders" him too much. And I always thought silver and black made it look the best =P.

I'm not a big Half-Life fan, but from what this says I can see that he has a very nice array of abilities in that suit.

With that I'll keep Freeman in first (due to lack of knowlege and u make it sound pretty convincing), Chief to second, Fett to third.

Other than that I enjoyed reading the intelligent yet clever comments about each person. I say keep goin.

I don't see how Freeman can come in first for the armor.  I believe the helmet still counts as armor.  If the enemies you played against were smart, one well placed sniper shot or any weapon for that matter could take you out.
Otherwise great job, I really enjoy it!

I don't think he was saying MC is slow I think he was trying to say that MCs no gymnast, you know like flips and roles. (I always wanted to role in halo like this: "NADE!" *Role Role* "whiew that was clos...Ahhh it's a stickie one Ahhhhhhhh..." *BOOM!*) :o

boba would rock him

Him who? Also, it is helpful to explain reasoning for posts such as yours.

Very smart thinking with these comparisons.

Ok, got some sleep and am ready to continue:
12.Vehicles
Fett: Slave 1. Nothing else need be said.
Cheif: Warthogs, tanks, and some stolen Covenant ships.
Freeman: A rickity hoverboat and a suped-up dune buggy.
Winner: Fett. Freeman and Cheif tie.
13. Relationships
Fett: Has a kid with a woman then dumps her.  Some guy.
Cheif: None, unless you count an A.I.'s remark that his body is simular in structure to a space cruiser. Still don't know if she was hitting on him.
Freeman: Is good friends with many scientists, and has something in the works with Alyx Vance.
Winner: Freeman. Cheif comes second. Fett really should lose some points.

New total:
Fett:15
Cheif:14
Freeman:16

I know someones going to complain now that I've put Freeman in the lead.

I doubt that Freeman being a theoretical scientist would help him fight Fett. Also dont sell Fett's intellegence short, he's very strategic and has a very battle-wary mind, like Masterchief's.
Also Fett doesnt work for the Empire, he's just done jobs for them but he doesnt necessarily work for them.

Freeman is dumb,that's all I can say,compared to the other two.

Well who asked you?

Oh, I did.

Well, this isn't about a straight out knock down fight, it's a comparison.  There is no real answer in that situation.  If fett had time to plan, he'd probabl win.  If all three of them just walked in a room and started shooting, Cheif would probably win.  If the three were trying to kill the other two in a reactor chamber, Freeman would be the only one standing not having died from radiation poisioning upon entry. So that's why I'm using comparison, and not "Cheif could so kick fett's butt" arguments.  And Fett does work for the Empire, it's just he works like a contractor, instead of full time grunt.

I really don't think I need your permission to say anything here.So don't ever say something like this again,because the way you say it,you sound like the boss.And certainly you are not the Boss.

ummmmm... it was a JOKE.
are you really that silly?
I think that this is a fine topic I mean this is what this site is for and I like just being a silly fan and comparing pointless things.

????????????????

Sweet job of contributing. (try to use more ?'s next time, it really gets your point across)

While I don't always agree with his methods, FMR (snazzy new nickname for Force Master R) was most likely trying to point out the fact that your post was sorta useless. Why do you think Freeman is stupid? Why are the other two smarter than him? Questions that need to be answered.

MEANWHILE BACK ON TOPIC...

While I agree that Slave 1 completely blows the other vehicles in this comparison out of the water... are you truly saying that Freeman's little buggy matches up to the warthog? And the corpion tank has met its equal in a hover boat? I don't really see the equivelancy. And what about the longswords and pelicans he has access to?

Fett, Chief, Freeman I say...

sorry

I say Boba could kill Gordan. His weapons are nothing compared to a blaster.
Boba verses chief would be difficult. Though MC could beat him in a fist fight, if Fett didn't stab him with his arm vibro-blades, I would say Boba would win. MC dies from ONE rocket in Halo and Halo 2. In Star Wars, they have a couple of hundred years of advanced technology including tracking rockets. One missile from Fett's Jetpack could blow up a tank, nevermind the chief himself. Plus, blasters are advanced plasma guns, not the crude random ones in Halo. An EE-3 rifle could cut through the Chief's shields.
So Fett would win.

If  everyone explained everything in one post,then this wouldn't be a conversation,right?More like an essay.And sorry but I won't accept criticism from you,fetter.Just do your job and let me do mine.As for indulging your never ending curiosity,I believe that Master Chief and Boba have the experience and tactical skills that Freeman can't match,even with his tremendous I.Q.

P.S I quoted Karson to point the fact that I don't make useless posts(no offence in any way.)

If everyone explained the point of their post in their post, it would be a spam-free conversation. If you do not accept helpful critisism, you can never grow.

You're right draco,but it wasn't helpful.Let's just leave it at that,please and continue with this fine(like Alo Fett said after he insulted me)topic.I won't speak of this any longer.

Hello Boba Fett Fan!

Weren't we just talking about spamming and relative posts?

I think he was trying to say hello to the new guy.  His post was a little late but nothing too bad.

As stated in the begining, I can't just write out a straight out knock down fight, because of the fact that, because the three are from differnt universes, we will never know weapon power, armour strength, or other such comparisons.  Thats why I say if you dissagree with a listing, or think I left one out, to post it. Like...

1st, thanks for the snazzy new nickname.  2nd thank you for clarifying what I said. Even if Maul's clone still won't accept it. And 3rd, looking back I agree, and so will change the running totals to...

New total:
Fett:15
Cheif:14
Freeman:15
Results in Fett and Freeman in a tie, with Cheif still in last.

So once again, if you think that I left out a listing or dissagree with one of the listings, post it, rather than ethier saying "Freeman would so get his butt handed back to him." or posting a senario.

If you have strength and intelligence, you should probably have speed and stealth. Out of the three, I only know of Fett to a good deal, so I should not answer either of those. I think that John gets the point for speed, though.

The Boba Fett vs MC was argued earlier, so I'm not going to do it again.  As for Freeman, I liked the HL games, but I really don't understand whats up with him.  Sure, his suit can inject him with stuff, but is that really going to help a bullet wound? They make him into a super hero, without actually making him a super hero.  If that makes any sense.

The tech in the Halo universe is not as advanced as the Star Wars universe. (except for the energy shields and armor)  MastercChief can take several rocket hits unless their dead-on, and that would be fairly hard to do. 

Let's do this simply.  If you took away all external help, (weapons, armor, vehicles, etc.) Chief would win by a long shot.  He's the only one who has super-human strength and reflexes, and has a tactical mind to rival, if not surpass Fett. 

And why is everyone mis-spelling Chief?  I before e, people.

If you took away weapons then whats the point? It becomes a boxing match.

One thing is this all looks good on paper but if they were pitted against each other through some impossible odds, I'm going to say it will be a close battle between Fett and Master Chief but Fett pulls it off.  There are better places to greet new members such as introduction to the boards topic.

I agree with Sev, Freeman wouldn't last too long and it would be up to MC and Fett. Fett would most likely pull it off in the end because I think he's just that little bit better than MC.

ahem..... back to weapons hows does freeman win i mean he lifts fett up with the gravity gun and gets in a whack or two then boba just shoots his miniature missile.

Ehem this is just turning into a standard vs match it was sposed to be based on the point system Force Master was doing.

THANK YOU!
Yes IG-88 is right this is NOT Boba MC and Gordon in a cage mach.
It is comparing the differn't attributes of all becu'z the (as seen in Fett vs MC) the cage mach scenario never go's anywhere. This is a good way of COMPARING not V.S.ing (I don't care what the title say's).
It show's how cool/good the ones in queston are dispite time, strength, and weapons.

Thank you little bro. You too IG-88.
Why oh why can't people read my comments.  People, there are limitless ways to do comparisons  that favor anyone of the three.  Here's one.  Tight hallway with limited cover.  Freeman use's combine rifle's secondary shot.  Fett and Chief are ashes.  Heck, I could make Indianna Jones win.  Every one watches as the Ark of the covenant is opened by nazi.  Everyone but Indy is killed by the wrath of God.  See? It's pointless to use senarios for this because everyone (well, almost everyone) can win when a match is put in their favor. Hence the Tally sheet method.

My brother reminded me that Baba's Jet pack is a gadgett, one which I forgot to post.  But I still think the gravity gun is better, so I'm not changing anything.

I agree with IG-88.

Hey dont rag on Indy! What has he ever done to you?

He was not "ragging" on Indy. He did not mention any names, and even if he did, he was not insulting in any way. He was merely pointing out a fact.

To get back on topic, who would have the points for speed or stealth?

I believe Boba is for speed,and Freeman is for stealth.

I agree with Draco.

Joke, by the way. And yes he did mention a name. He said he could even make Indiana Jones win, implying that theres no way he could win.

Next time be a little mre telling.

So should you for that matter. Your posts on this thread haven't exactly been too "telling".

By Indy, I thought you ment a new member, whose name I could only partially remember.

I think that John (Master Chief) gets the point for speed. Someone stated earlier that he can run at thirty-seven miles per hour.

Oh ok forget everything.

10 miles per hour isn't that fast.  Fetter stated the MC has been clocked at 60 km/h.

I love Indy!  Can't wait to see him in #4!  It's just that, seeing as he's using weapons that are from the 30's and has no armour, people would general state that he'd lose any vs. senario.  I personaly think Indy could beat both Chief and Fett at the same time, just don't ask me how. 

Anyway, to put in draco's cry for stealth and speed and my deciding to add split second tactics, which I will refer to as "wits", here goes...
14. Speed
Fett: He can run pretty fast and has a jet pack for extra speed... he just can't fly all the time.
Chief: "Hey guys, watch my run past that Zebra!"
Freeman: He can sprint at like, 10 mph for ten seconds...
Winner: Cheif, running laps around the others. Fett second, with freeman still at the gate...
15. Stealth
Fett: He can be stealthy when he want to be stealthy.  Heck, he can kill everyone in a bugged room with 2 bounty hunters outside have no one the wiser that it was me.
Chief: He try to be stealthy, but he alway end up either being spotted or blowing somthing up in 2 seconds.
Freeman: Sure he's stealthy.  But his stealth allmost always involves "Jumping out of the frying pan and into the fire."  Sure, the combine won't find you, but who want's to look for someone in a town full of zombies?
Winner: Fett sneaks off with the trophie.  Freeman quietly takes second, with Cheif blowing up everything in third.
16. Wits
Fett: Most of Fett's moves are planned long in advance.  Never does a job by "making it up as he goes along."  He can think on his feet, after all, it keeps him alive long enough to put his long thought out plan into action.
Chief: Being crash landed on an alien planet, vastly out-numbered, he not only survived, he won.  Most of his thinking was "If it moves, shoot it untill it stops moving" to be sure, but what other plan is their when you stumble on intelligent fugus zombies deep underground?
Freeman: His entire life is on the fly.  What with being chased weaponless through the sewers, being abandoned in a zombie filled town, running into every combine checkpoint on a giant bug infested freeway, to leading a spur of the moment revolution, to running through the enemys own tower weaponless again, he better be quick with a plan.
Winner: Freeman.  Cheif in second with Fett in third.

New total:
Fett: 18
Cheif:17
Freeman:18

I agree these stats are good and the points make sense.

I soooo agree with everything right there. He could beat them all, definitly. Me and you FMR, we know its true. :)
I'm slightly obsessed with Indy.
Back on topic, yes the stealth, wits, and speed I think are pretty accurate. I think that no matter what category's get added Freeman is still going to lose to MC and Fett however.(when all the points are tallied that is)

Long live Indy!  He who justly has his place as the number two Hero of all time, according to the AFI.  May he live on forever.

And currently, Fett and Freeman are tied for 1st, so if Chief is going to get back in the running someone had beeter post somthing that he'd beat both Fett and Freeman in.

I vote for Gordon Freeman because, We share the same last name :D